6 Comments
User's avatar
Andrew Berg's avatar

Great points here.

Another related angle I sometimes point out is that while Jesus’ way is always ultimately good news, it doesn’t always FEEL like good news at first. For example, when Jesus talks to the rich young ruler and tells him to sell all his possessions, or even to the disciples when he first teaches how the Son of Man must suffer and die. Sometimes the way of Jesus might require some big changes. But that doesn’t mean he doesn’t love us. Those hard painful changes might actually be really for our ultimate good.

Frederick Schmidt's avatar

I would have amended the definition of love that you shared to read as follows: “Love is a deliberate act of the will to show care, concern, and affection for another person on their journey into God in Christ, even when we don’t feel like it.” That journey is the characteristic feature of the Christian definition of love, its doctrine of salvation, the Wesleyan as well as Orthodox understanding of sanctification\theosis, and the embodied life of the church. Neither our identity, nor our private definitions of dignity have anything to do with it. What is healed and restored in us is the image of God.

Doctrix Periwinkle's avatar

And let's note: Many of the things we want are bad for us, and bad for other people. For example: It's not love to affirm someone's addiction, which is making them miserable and making the lives of those around them miserable; it's love to help them go to rehab.

I think a problem progressive Christianity has is that it does not want to recognize sin. It's true that we are all of us beloved children of God made in His image, but it's also true that we are all fallen and have an inherent tendency to screw up. I think that progressive Christianity is very excited about the first part of that, but wants to completely ignore the second. I think that might be an outgrowth of the individualistic, capitalist culture that progressive Christianity grew in. Capitalism teaches us that every one of our desires deserves to be immediately sated, and individualism teaches us that we have obligations to no one but ourselves. Now, ultimately that's a miserable way to live: sating every material desire as soon as it pops up does not make desire go away, but makes it grow more ravenous; living only for oneself leads to loneliness and depression. I know that many progressive Christians self-define as economically leftist, which is what makes it ironic that they've bought so wholeheartedly into the capitalist framing of how humans should live, treating every life decision as another banal consumer choice that cannot be criticized.

Loren Richmond Jr.'s avatar

This reminds me of Andrew Root’s last book where he talks about capitalism and escalation of the “identititarians.” I certainly could have quoted him in this.

Seth Cain's avatar

It seems what we are first expected to “affirm” or adopt is arguably a late modern framework on identity. We want to radically love LGBT people as people. But are we able to question whether the composite of anyone’s identity assigns so much weight to sexual attraction? It would seem, no. At present, we can’t revisit or question the framework. We can’t do any ethnography, either. To do so is considered unloving or even bigoted. I guess my discomfort is primarily in the compulsion we are under to accept what amount to assumptions, well-meaning as they are. And these assumptions now put sexuality out of the realm of self-denial or any moral implication.

Loren Richmond Jr.'s avatar

I do have a follow-up piece coming speaking more directly to your point that to be considered inclusive means to accept certain ideologies.