TL:DR: Within progressive Christianity, love and affirmation sometimes seem to be treated as interchangeable. But are they? God's love is unconditional, yet God's grace is also transformative. Drawing on Wesleyan theology, this essay explores why Christian love means more than affirming people as they are. The gospel isn't simply a divine stamp of approval on our lives, but an invitation into the healing, restoration, and transformation made possible through Jesus Christ.



What Does It Mean to Love?
Years ago, when I was a senior in high school attending Arvada Baptist Church, our youth director at the time, Leonard Dueck (I think that was his name), began teaching about love. He was insistent that love was not a feeling or an emotion, as it was so often portrayed in the rom-coms of the 1990s, but rather a willful choice. He even went so far as to print business-card-sized handouts with his definition of love. It was something like this:
Love is a deliberate act of the will to show care, concern, and affection for another person, even when we don’t feel like it.
While this definition of Christian love—or at least my recollection of it—certainly came from a conservative Christian context, it was formative in my young adulthood, especially as I entered marriage. It helped me understand love not simply as a feeling or emotion that might come and go, but as a deliberate act of the will.
In the years since, as I’ve made my way into more liberal and progressive Christian contexts, I’ve found myself returning to that definition. Not because I think it captures everything Christian love entails, but because I’ve increasingly wondered whether we’ve begun to confuse love with affirmation.
When Love Becomes Affirmation
I’ve been thinking quite a bit lately about what it means to be inclusive, particularly within progressive Christianity. And I have to admit, I’m finding myself increasingly confused, and perhaps even flummoxed at times. To that end, I’m going to be developing a series on diversity and inclusion within progressive Christian contexts—consider this post the first in that series.
I’ve increasingly noticed, especially within progressive Christian circles, a tendency to equate love with affirmation. At least, that’s my interpretation of what I’m seeing, and I recognize that others may understand these conversations differently.
This is something I think about as a parent myself, and theologically, as I hear again and again within progressive Christian circles something to the effect of, “God loves us exactly as we are,” with the presumed conclusion being, “and God would never ask us to change.”
Yes, God loves us unconditionally. God’s grace is extravagant and undeserved. But I don’t think God is simply content with us remaining as we are.
What I mean is this: It sometimes seems that within progressive Christian circles, to “love” someone means not only to care for them, respect them, and seek their well-being, but also to affirm everything about them. And if we don’t offer that affirmation, we’re told that we’re not really loving them.
But I can’t help but wonder—is that really how Christian love works?
Maybe I’m wrong. Maybe I’m mishearing the words and intent; that’s entirely possible.
To be clear, I do think there’s a difference between affirming someone’s dignity and worth as a human being—a child of God, created in the image of God, and one for whom Christ died—and affirming their beliefs, behaviors, and moral convictions. To me, those are not the same things.
And while affirmation can mean acknowledging, validating, or supporting something about another person, it seems like we’ve increasingly come to use it as a kind of unquestioning acceptance, without any expectation of change.
When I repeatedly hear, “God loves us exactly as we are,” and sometimes even something to the effect of, “God would never ask us to change,” I wonder: Is this really what it means to love?
God’s Love Is Unconditional—but Is God’s Affirmation?
Christian love, as I understand it, holds together two convictions: that God’s love is unconditional and that God’s grace is also transformative. And that applies to all of us, myself included.
Certainly, love requires us to take seriously the experiences of others. And there are times when love demands that we reconsider our own assumptions, repent of our prejudices, or change our behavior.
But love has never meant that we must agree with everything another person believes.
I’m technically not Methodist, but as I worked for a bit for a Methodist church, now attend a Methodist church, and my daughter recently went through Methodist confirmation, I’ve been reading quite a bit about Wesleyan theology. As I understand it, Methodists sometimes describe God’s grace using the image of a house.
In short, God’s prevenient grace is like a warm and welcoming front porch, seeking to draw all people inside. Yet we’re invited to do more than simply stand on the porch, looking in. And God’s justifying grace enables us to enter through the door.
But once we enter, God’s grace doesn’t simply leave us unchanged.
As Mark Maddix writes, “Wesleyan theology is primarily transformative…it is transformational” (24).
Later in the same book, Maddix adds that for Wesley, “salvation includes the entire Christian life, not just the initial moment of belief. The transformation of humanity in the person of Jesus can be categorized into three stages of reconciliation, new birth, and participation” (100).
At a minimum, it seems that God does not expect us to remain the people we already are.
This is not to say that human beings are inherently broken and ruined, as some interpretations of Calvinist theology might suggest. In fact, this is one of the reasons I’ve been drawn to Wesleyan theology.
Again, Maddix notes, “the human being is not essentially sinful. That is, humans in the condition of sin, are distorted away from their original, relational design” (73).
The point, as I understand it, is that God’s grace is not simply about accepting us as we are, but restoring us to who we were created to be.
Can We Love Without Affirming?
Traditionally, I’ve understood dignity and respect to mean recognizing the inherent worth of another person and treating them accordingly. It means showing kindness, exercising compassion, listening carefully, and refusing to reduce another human being to their beliefs, behaviors, or identity.
And from a Christian perspective, our dignity isn’t something bestowed upon us by society or earned through our moral correctness; it’s rooted in our creation in the imago Dei, or image of God.
Of course, dignity and respect cannot be reduced to simply being nice to people. Our institutions, policies, and practices matter, too. We can treat someone with kindness in our personal interactions while participating in systems that fail to recognize their dignity or adequately protect their well-being.
But what does respecting that dignity require of us?
Increasingly, it seems that dignity and respect are also understood as requiring affirmation of someone’s understanding of themselves, along with support for the social and political arrangements they believe are necessary for their flourishing.
Now, I don’t want to dismiss that understanding.
But acknowledging the importance of dignity doesn’t necessarily tell us what every moral or political conclusion ought to be. We may share a commitment to human dignity while disagreeing about what honoring that dignity requires in particular circumstances or policy positions.
Maddix adds these words that I think are especially worthwhile to the conversation: “Wesley preached that God in God’s mercy holds the life of an individual to be of greater importance than that individual’s ideas” (145).1
From another Wesleyan theologian I’ve become quite fond of, the late Mildred Bangs Wynkoop: “Faith then, to Wesley was much more than belief… Faith has an ethical meaning. It means a realignment of life to please God” (67).
The life of faith, at least as far as I can tell from a Wesleyan perspective, is not simply about a divine stamp of approval on who we already are, but rather a loving, gracious invitation from God to all people to come and be transformed.
The Non-Affirming Nature of God’s Love
There does seem to be, again at least from a Wesleyan perspective, a sort of what I might awkwardly call a “non-affirming nature” of God’s love.
As another Wesleyan source puts it, “There is such a thing as healthy self-denial. It is what Jesus asks of us” (45).
If we take community too lightly, as Reuben Job suggests, and individualism too seriously, we can neglect “our call to faithfulness to the gospel of Jesus Christ” (11).
In other words, God’s love doesn’t simply affirm our individual desires or understandings of ourselves. It calls us into something beyond ourselves, into a life shaped by Christ and lived in community with others.
Are We Teaching Biblical Love?
This is, I suppose, what I really want to get to: I think much of what gets promoted within liberal and progressive Christian spaces—and even Methodist spaces, if I may be so bold—doesn’t actually fit with a Christian understanding of love.
To say that God loves someone is not necessarily to say that God affirms everything about them. And as we live in a society that increasingly seems to equate love with complete affirmation, I think it’s important to differentiate the two. They are not the same.
Now, let me be clear on this, lest some think I’m asking folks to read between the lines and decode a secret message.
This piece is not meant to be a subtle argument against LGBT inclusion, even if I find myself increasingly uneasy with the language of “affirming.” As I’ve sought to describe here, my concern is with the way affirmation can come to mean unquestioning acceptance, without any expectation of change.
What I think God calls humans to, and what the grace of God compels us toward, is not the status quo but life transformation. It means submitting every part of our lives to Christ.
And to be crystal clear, I fully believe one can be an LGBT person and completely submitted to God’s love, grace, and provision. I know too many such persons to doubt otherwise.
But I think churches do themselves, the gospel, and our Christian theology a disservice when we use language such as “God loves us as we are” or “God affirms us” in ways that suggest God has no desire to transform us.
The gospel is not about a “divine stamp of approval” on our lives, but instead a sacrament of radical transformation by which we find healing and restoration.2
And this is perhaps why I ultimately dislike the language of affirmation, particularly when it becomes the primary way we describe God’s love. It strikes me as an entirely human-centered understanding of faith, one that risks treating religion, faith, and even God as existing to affirm and validate us, rather than recognizing our desperate need for the love, grace, and healing made known in Jesus.
I’m now realizing Maddix was one of the editors and these might now be his actual words. Alas.
Methodists use sacramental language, right?



Great points here.
Another related angle I sometimes point out is that while Jesus’ way is always ultimately good news, it doesn’t always FEEL like good news at first. For example, when Jesus talks to the rich young ruler and tells him to sell all his possessions, or even to the disciples when he first teaches how the Son of Man must suffer and die. Sometimes the way of Jesus might require some big changes. But that doesn’t mean he doesn’t love us. Those hard painful changes might actually be really for our ultimate good.
I would have amended the definition of love that you shared to read as follows: “Love is a deliberate act of the will to show care, concern, and affection for another person on their journey into God in Christ, even when we don’t feel like it.” That journey is the characteristic feature of the Christian definition of love, its doctrine of salvation, the Wesleyan as well as Orthodox understanding of sanctification\theosis, and the embodied life of the church. Neither our identity, nor our private definitions of dignity have anything to do with it. What is healed and restored in us is the image of God.